Bloggers vs. Librarians?
or Why We Shouldn't Choose Sides & More...
With ALA Annual having ended just last week, in comes the drama. Yes, even in the world of books, there is loads of drama. Who starts this drama? Oh, I really don't know. I really have no idea. I was enjoying the talk of books on Twitter just a few nights ago, look away for a few minutes, come back, and my feed is full of drama. I groaned to myself as I scrolled through the mass of tweets, and was struck by a ton of terrible things that I couldn't believe were being said.
Things such as "Bloggers are taking books from librarians at ALA" or "Bloggers are grabbing everything in sight and librarians don't get a chance to get as many books." People acting like bloggers and librarians are enemies, that blogger and librarians are sides of some battle, like you need to choose a side, like librarians and bloggers aren't friends who want to discuss books with each other. What kind of community is this, if people are pitting bloggers and librarians against one another? What kind of book community are we if all we worry about are ARCs? It's definitely not the community I want to be a part of!
I started tweeting about the drama the night I saw it, and got over 50 tweets back at me. Bloggers, librarians, teachers, all bombarding me. A few librarians were being particularly dramatic. One of them told me that I said that I was entitled to books at ALA, that ARCs were my right to have and grab at ALA. I looked through my tweets, and not one time did I ever say I was entitled. It's so infuriating, that a few librarians are trying to make all bloggers look bad about one overgrabbing book blogger!
Don't nake steretypes about bloggers because you didn't get as many ARCs as a greedy one. Since when do ARCs mean the world? Last time I checked, people were whining that bloggers were being greedy about ARCs. Well, how come when librarians don't end up with their ARCs, they feel that they have a right to whine on Twitter about it, and twist people's words around about it? I find this hypocritical and so just...INFURIATING. I mean, don't preach about not caring about ARCs then want to start a ton of drama about how you're little tote bag wasn't filled with enough.
Note, I am talking about a few librarians, I am not in any way stereotyping all librarians!
But this post isn't about librarians (only a few) being annoying about ARCs.
This post is to ask: Why the heck are we choosing sides?
This post is to ask ANYONE why were are suddenly choosing sides. Bloggers or librarians? That's becoming a question on Twitter. That's becoming a battle in tweets. I love librarians with all my heart. They keep kids reading, they put books in reluctant reader's hands. They are the reason that I love reading. And, from whom I have met, librarians love bloggers! At ALA, I met over thirty librarians, and all of them loved bloggers, all of them asked for my card, all of them were so sweet, all of them wanted to discuss the latest books, the latest news in the YA world. That is what I love about the book community, we are all willing to share our thoughts, our opinions, about all things YA, and in the end still be friends.
So why are some librarians and bloggers trying to make it so we can't do this anymore?
I think the beginning of the drama started when a certain ALA attendee (who HAPPENED to be a book blogger) posted a video of her ALA book haul. Her sister also went with her, and they each grabbed their own copies of all the books. And I agree with everyone out there, that is seriously ridiculous. Why would you not just SHARE one copy with the person that you are living with?
But then, librarians and teachers and different kinds of people on Twitter started doing that thing that makes EVERY blogger mad: stereotyping. Tweets were popping up saying "Bloggers are taking books from librarians," and "Bloggers are being greedy" because one or two book bloggers overgrabbed. And now, suddenly, the ENTIRE BOOK BLOGGING COMMUNITY overgrabbed and were greedy.
I was not greedy. I got a total of 60 books from ALA Annual. I plan to read every single book that I sent home. And I know that some bloggers grabbed over 150 books, and they do not plan on reading even half of them. I have seen a ton of book hauls that are even a modest thirty books! And yet bloggers like me are being put into the category of that one blogger who grabbed 200 books! And it is infuriating.
And now, I am going to deliver my biggest point.
Since when is all that bloggers and librarians care about are ARCs?
I know that ARCs are an extremely big part of the publishing industry nowadays. I know this very well. But since when is blogging done to get ARCs? I know that I started blogging, and I didn't hear about the idea of ARCs for at least two months. Did I work harder on my blog when I found out I could get ARCs? Sure! I don't mean to sound like all egotistic, but I think I produce pretty thorough content on my blog. My reviews are pretty long, I do blog tours, giveaways, and I do discussions, and I spend a ton of time on these posts! Does any of this make me feel entitled to ARCs? HECK NO! ARCs are a mini reward for me! But not in any way a right.
What am I trying to say?
Just because one blogger over grabbed at ALA does not mean anyone has the right to stereotype the blogging community for a few bloggers actions.
Just because one librarian is saying that bloggers took books from them, this does not mean that we are on different sides. Because I love librarians, and I have met so many librarians that are interested in reading YA blogs to find out what books to put in their libraries.
There are no sides. We are all lovers of books, we are all friends who want to share our thoughts on books. And that is what I love about blogging and reading. But for some people to try and make it that way is beyond me.
Tell me in the comments!
Do you disagree with me?
What do you think of the people pitting librarians and bloggers against one another?
What do you think of over-grabbers?
What do you think of bloggers in general? Do you think they deserve to be stereotyped?
What are your experiences with librarian-blogger interaction?